One word turns out to bracket a career. Bob is reading his own commentary on page 155 when he notices, for the first time, that it opens on Pollstergeist , and Cameron immediately asks whether McLuhan hadn’t used the same word in The Mechanical Bride — his first book, against an essay published in the last year of his life. Halfway through the session Cameron finds the sentence on page 47 and reads it out , and the two ends close on each other. What sits between them is the machinery of a reputation: the postures the classifiers hung on McLuhan, the friend who got his first book printed and was written out of the record, and the one admission Bob says McLuhan made to him twice .
Key Topics
- The Pollstergeist is corrected out of the occult and into media: not a possessing spirit but audience research, “the probing of the audience to find out what the trends are” .
- The Tiny Note Chart is re-read under a single variable, its quadrants becoming five phases of cyborg involvement rather than five periods .
- Cameron bounds Kroker precisely — he saw what McLuhan saw, but not the way out of the cul-de-sac, and the difference is the freedom that let McLuhan remain Catholic .
- Felix Giovannelli is recovered from near-total obscurity as the man “primarily responsible for the Mechanical Bride ever being published” , and as the introduction that carried McLuhan to the Southern critics .
- McLuhan’s own account of his reception: an “anticipated cursory inspection” that made the books look confused, with the critics’ complaint offered as proof the technique worked .
- The tech body arrives not as an adversary but as a provider, running the honchos’ chicanery while leaving the user the sensation of command .
Notable Quotes
"this spontaneous outburst of joy suggests that there was a very widespread and suppressed anxiety about the human effects of the Pollstergeist operations."
"So I say McLuhan told me two separate times that he miscalculated global management."
"It doesn't look like it's an enemy. It's a lover."
Outline
- 0:00:01 — Opening: Pollstergeist on page 155
- 0:04:17 — The Pollstergeist is the environment
- 0:08:59 — Visualization and the monster
- 0:12:45 — Finnegans Wake as the accurate form
- 0:18:00 — The Tiny Note Chart: five phases of the cyborgian
- 0:22:48 — Kroker: panic writing and the Catholic difference
- 0:29:20 — New York, 1993–2008: Augustine at the end of the empire
- 0:44:32 — Why chronology: the global Esperanto of imagery
- 0:48:51 — Comedy as the underlying language
- 0:52:39 — McLuhan the greatest actor
- 0:54:52 — The Mechanical Bride sentence
- 01:04:16 — Cochrane, Innis, and the inside of the hick
- 01:14:38 — Autonomy and the election of roles
- 01:20:48 — Cursory inspection: the postures McLuhan adopted
- 01:32:17 — Felix Giovannelli and the making of The Mechanical Bride
- 01:38:46 — The memory theater sentence
- 01:47:29 — Understanding Media p.130: the simulation of consciousness
- 01:56:19 — Global management and the hijacking
- 02:06:51 — The tech body as lover
- 02:16:28 — Take Today: superhumanization wrecks the system
Mentioned Resources
Works by McLuhan
- The Mechanical Bride (1951) — page 47 supplies the Pollstergeist sentence and the November 1948 Dewey–Truman passage; Typhon was the working title before it
- Understanding Media — page 130 on languages as “stuttering extensions of our five senses” and the simulation of consciousness
- From Cliché to Archetype — page 160 for the mini-module, page 155 for rippling repetition
- Take Today — page 221 on electric superhumanization, page 297 on innovation and obsolescence
- The Gutenberg Galaxy — the postures of individual mind, spelled out by Alexander Pope
- Laws of Media — its closing “unchartable milieu,” and the vagueness Cameron hears in it
- Counterblast (1969) — Hollywood as “Barnum and Bailey hijackers”
- “The Hijacking of Cities, Nations, and Planets” — the 1971 varsity Explorations essay
- Maclean’s, January 7, 1980 — the late essay the session reads, finished by Eric McLuhan
Other Works
- Arthur Kroker, The Possessed Individual — each postmodern French writer read as acting out a possession
- Charles Reich, The Greening of America — credited with prompting “the user is the content”
- Frances Yates — her book on the memory theatre, the reason the phrase sits in quotation marks
- Herbert Marcuse — one-dimensionality, offered as a description of an environment that eats everything
- James Joyce, Finnegans Wake — the form Bob says is the only accurate description of collective dialogue
- Woody Allen, Annie Hall (1977) — McLuhan’s cameo and “my whole fallacy is wrong”
People
- Marshall McLuhan (the Toronto media theorist whose work the series reads)
- Eric McLuhan (his son and collaborator; finished the 1980 Maclean’s essay after the stroke)
- Arthur Kroker (theorist of panic writing and surplus flesh)
- Felix Giovannelli (St. Louis friend who got The Mechanical Bride published and introduced McLuhan to the Southern critics)
- Bernard Muller-Thym (the third of the St. Louis circle, who left in 1942)
- Charles Cochrane (classicist at the University of Toronto who gave Innis the Greeks)
- Harold Innis (Canadian communication theorist; source of the fascination with the reporter)
- John Crowe Ransom (editor of the Kenyon Review, who recommended McLuhan for the Sewanee editorship)
- Allen Tate (poet whose resignation opened that editorship)
- Cleanth Brooks (Southern critic McLuhan met in 1942 through Giovannelli)
- Ezra Pound (correspondent; the Bollingen Prize split the circle)
- Gerald Phelan (the mentor behind the University of Toronto Quarterly publications)
- Ted Carpenter (the meeting Bob sets against the editorship never taken)
- Donald Theall (McLuhan’s student; the “new Illuminati” lineage from Egypt to Canada)
- Talcott Parsons (systems sociologist; the subject of Kroker’s thesis)
- T. Lobsang Rampa (author whose prediction about Canada Bob re-reads as perception)
- Jack Nicholson (actor who based the Head script on McLuhan’s theories)
- Corinne McLuhan (whose friendships Cameron writes back into the St. Louis circle)
Closing
This is the session where McLuhan’s reputation is taken apart and rebuilt as a method: the confusion was designed, the postures were the work, and the one thing he admitted getting wrong was how long management could hold the door shut.
← The Trap Door to the Wake: Scapes, the Five Bodies, and Module as Meme